Monday, November 17, 2025

IN DEFENSE OF TRADITIONALISM

150 men building a house for a family that was lost it in a fire

How can 150 men build a house in a week? It's called division of labor! 

From the cutting of the wood. Masons, plumbers, electricians. Carpenters assemble the structural framework. Other workers prepare and transport lumber. Teams raise walls and install beams. Roofers work on the roof. Experienced craftsmen supervise and coordinate the work. 

Meanwhile, women organize meals, and younger members participate in appropriate tasks. THAT'S TRADITION

Tradition has become an increasingly contested subject in contemporary society. 

In much of today's media, traditions are frequently portrayed as outdated conventions, obstacles to progress, or instruments of social oppression. 

While some criticisms are justified—after all, not every inherited practice deserves preservation—there is a tendency to dismiss tradition altogether, overlooking its fundamental role in human life. 

Traditions are not simply remnants of the past; they are repositories of collective experience, accumulated knowledge, moral principles, and cultural identity. 

They provide continuity between generations, establish shared expectations, and create the social bonds that make communities possible. 

Questioning a particular tradition may be legitimate; assuming that tradition itself is an obstacle to human flourishing is a different and much more consequential proposition. It is therefore important to understand what traditions are, why societies develop them, and what we stand to lose when we discard them without careful consideration.

1. What is tradition?

Tradition is accumulated historical experience transmitted across generations.

Element

Example

Shared historical experience

A community that has lived through hurricanes develops customary practices for preparing homes, storing supplies, and helping neighbors.

Customs

Greeting people, celebrating birthdays, preparing particular meals for holidays.

Rituals

Weddings, funerals, religious ceremonies, graduation ceremonies.

Conventions

Shaking hands, waiting in line, respecting personal space.

Precedents

Courts relying on previous decisions when resolving similar cases.

Accumulated practical intelligence

Farmers learning which crops grow best in particular soils through generations of experience.

An important example: language.

Nobody invents a language individually. We inherit vocabulary, grammar, expressions, and meanings. We can modify language, but we cannot simply invent a functioning language overnight and expect an entire society to adopt it.

Tradition works similarly: it provides an inherited framework within which innovation becomes possible.

2. Why do traditions matter?

A. Social cohesion and group identity

Traditions create a sense of belonging and collective identity.

  • Example 1: Thanksgiving. Families gather around a shared meal, often repeating practices passed down for generations. The ritual reinforces family identity even when members disagree about politics or other matters.

  • Example 2: Cuban cultural traditions. Music, food, dance, and celebrations help preserve a sense of cultural identity across generations, including among people living outside Cuba.

  • Example 3: National commemorations. Memorial Day in the United States creates a shared occasion for remembering military service and sacrifice.

Durkheim would describe these practices as mechanisms of social solidarity.

B. Transmission of knowledge

Traditions preserve knowledge that cannot always be transmitted through books or formal instruction.

  • Example 1: Japanese craftsmanship. Traditional woodworking techniques are transmitted through apprenticeship, observation, and repetition. They learn under master carpenters for decades. Rooted in Shinto and Buddhist reverence for trees as living things, the craft emphasizes patience, minimalism, discipline, and letting the natural beauty of materials like hinoki cypress and sugi cedar shine

  • Example 2: Agriculture. Farmers inherit knowledge about planting seasons, soil conditions, irrigation, and crop rotation. 

  • Example 3: Cooking. A traditional recipe often involves techniques learned through observation: how to knead dough, recognize when a sauce is ready, or judge the oil's temperature.

C. Meaning and orientation

Traditions provide symbolic frameworks through which people interpret their lives.

  • Example 1: Funeral rituals. They give structure to mourning and help communities collectively acknowledge death.

  • Example 2: Religious holidays. Christmas, Passover, Ramadan, and other celebrations connect everyday life with larger narratives of meaning.

  • Example 3: Coming-of-age ceremonies. These mark the transition from childhood to adulthood and communicate social expectations associated with maturity.

Without shared symbolic practices, individuals may still construct personal meanings, but collective meaning becomes more difficult to sustain.

D. Social trust and cooperation

Traditions establish expectations that make cooperation possible.

  • Example 1: The handshake. A conventional gesture of agreement and mutual recognition. One of the oldest known physical depictions is a relief carving showing Assyrian King Shalmaneser III shaking hands with the Babylonian king Marduk-zakir I to seal a political alliance

  • Example 2: Neighborhood assistance. In communities where helping neighbors is customary, residents may cooperate during emergencies without waiting for government intervention.

  • Example 3: Commercial reputation. A family business that has operated honestly for generations benefits from a reputation that encourages customers to trust it. Why are family businesses successful? Family businesses outperform non-family peers by roughly 3% annually and show lower bankruptcy rates because they combine long-term vision with unique cultural and operational advantages.

A useful illustration: imagine a society in which nobody considers a promise binding unless it is accompanied by a legal contract. The cost of social interaction would become enormous.

Tradition reduces the need to negotiate everything from the beginning.

3. How are traditions transmitted?

Institution

Example

What it transmits

Family

Parents teaching children to cook, share, and respect others

Values and habits

Education

Students learning classical literature and historical events

Cultural memory

Religion

Weekly services and annual celebrations

Moral frameworks and rituals

Apprenticeship

A carpenter teaching a young apprentice

Practical knowledge

Community

Local festivals and neighborhood celebrations

Collective identity

Institutions

Courts following established legal precedents

Continuity and stability

Example worth emphasizing: apprenticeship.

A young carpenter does not become a master simply by reading a book about carpentry. He learns through observation, imitation, correction, and years of practice.

The tradition of craftsmanship is therefore transmitted through a relationship between generations.

4. Tradition and social organization

A. Authority and responsibility

Authority is not necessarily arbitrary power. It can emerge from competence, experience, and responsibility.

Examples:

  • A surgeon directs an operating team because of specialized training and experience.

  • A teacher exercises authority in the classroom because of knowledge and pedagogical responsibility.

  • A ship captain makes decisions because the crew depends on coordinated leadership.

  • Parents establish boundaries for children because children have not yet developed the judgment required for independent decisions.

The important distinction: legitimate authority is connected to responsibility.

B. Hierarchy and differentiation

Hierarchies organize different functions within a community.

Examples:

  • The university: students, instructors, department chairs, deans, and presidents have different responsibilities.

  • The military: a chain of command allows coordinated action under difficult circumstances.

  • The orchestra: musicians have different roles, and the conductor coordinates the collective performance.

  • The medical profession: interns, residents, specialists, and senior physicians occupy different positions of experience and responsibility.

C. Reciprocity

Authority entails obligations toward those subject to it.

Examples:

  • Parents provide protection and education in exchange for the respect and cooperation expected of children.

  • Employers owe employees fair treatment and safe working conditions.

  • Political leaders owe citizens responsible government.

  • Teachers owe students competence, fairness, and intellectual honesty.

Traditionalism protects reciprocal obligations. Obedience to masters and elders is a means to an end, cultivating character, maintaining community order, expressing faith, or drawing closer to the divine.

5. Tradition and change

A. Adaptation

An existing tradition adjusts to changing circumstances.

  • Traditional farming communities adopt modern irrigation techniques without abandoning their agricultural knowledge.

  • Families maintain holiday celebrations but adapt them to accommodate relatives living in different countries.

  • Religious communities use modern communication technologies while preserving their ceremonies and beliefs.

B. Assimilation

A community incorporates new practices into an existing cultural framework.

  • Italian cuisine incorporated tomatoes, originally from the Americas, into what are now regarded as quintessentially Italian dishes.

  • Japanese culture incorporated Buddhism from abroad and developed distinctive Japanese religious traditions.

  • American cuisine incorporates influences from immigrant communities, producing new regional food traditions.

These examples demonstrate that traditions are not sealed systems. They can absorb foreign influences without necessarily losing their identity.

C. Space for Reform

An inherited institution changes in response to experience and criticism.

  • The abolition of slavery in the United States rejected an established institution that violated human freedom.

  • The expansion of women's educational opportunities challenged inherited restrictions.

  • Constitutional reforms can preserve a political system while correcting institutional deficiencies.

The distinction: reform does not necessarily require destroying the entire inherited order.

D. Arbitrary changes don't last

Examples of attempts to impose radical transformations without sufficient regard for existing social structures:

  • The Soviet campaign against religion, including the closure of churches, persecution of religious leaders, and restrictions on religious practice.

  • China's Cultural Revolution, during which traditional cultural and educational institutions were attacked.

  • The forced collectivization of agriculture under Stalin, which disrupted established rural communities and produced catastrophic consequences.

Friday, December 1, 2023

Tuesday, November 7, 2023

REVIEW FOR EXAM #2 (chapters 4 & 5)


Chapter 4 (philosophy of mind) pincha aquí. 

For videos on philosophy of mind, click here.

Chapter 5 (From Determinism to Libertarianismo) pincha aquí. 


Wednesday, October 27, 2021